Which is better? Maybelline liquid eyeliner or Unstoppable Kohl pencil liner?

i'm using the Unstoppable pencil liner and it sucks!!!! need a new one!Which is better? Maybelline liquid eyeliner or Unstoppable Kohl pencil liner?
With Maybelline liquid liner the line will stay crisp and sharp until you wet it or remove it--which is good if you want clean clear lines. Kohl pencil liner tends to smear--which is good if you want to achieve a ';smokey'; eye with blended lines and eyeshadow. I keep both in my kit.Which is better? Maybelline liquid eyeliner or Unstoppable Kohl pencil liner?
liquid eyeliner is better than kohl as most of them are waterproof %26amp; it won't smudge wen its dry.
My daughter uses revlon wet/dry pencil eyeliner. I tried it and love it. Stays on great.
I thought the pencil works quite welll.....
well personally i like liquid eyeliner for the top of my eyes it goes on easy and smooth and doesnt give a cakey look to it... for under my eyes i use a pencil and sum eyeshadow with a eyeliner brush...


stick with LIQUID EYELINER FOR THE TOP OF YOUR LID BY YOUR EYELASHES..


I TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU ON THE KOHL ..
i usually prefer pencils because i don't have a very steady hand and liquid looks awful if you don't do it well


but liquid gives a better effect when done well
personally, i do liquid liner on the top and then use a reg. pencil liner on the bottom, but thats just what works best for me, maybe you should give it a try.
Go with Unstoppable Kohl pencil liner. The pencil usually works better
try Revlon colorstay pencil
I use liquid eyeliners. It takes a while to get used to them and get good at lining the eye. They last longr than pencil eyeliners. The only thing I dont like is the goop on the inside of the eye that accumulates. Its no fun having black eyeboogers!