What is a good waterproof eye liner?

I am looking for a good water proof eyeliner pencil


I want one that goes on smooth and looks great all dayWhat is a good waterproof eye liner?
i use the wet n wild H20 proof liquid liner. it's a bit hard to take off (will not budge, will not come off with soap and water), but you can let makeup remover sit on your eye for about 10 seconds, and it'll come right off.





it's only $3.99 at most drugstores, and it works better than the high end liners i've used before.What is a good waterproof eye liner?
Everyone says that MAC makeup is amazing...but I hate their eyeliner.





If you want something affordable, buy the Expert Eyes eyeliner from Maybelline. It lasts all day. It's great. I've been using it for years.





:)
I've tried all of them and the best waterproof is M.A.C. PowerPoint. It used to be Lancome Khol but they stopped making it in waterproof. For drugstore brands, L'Oreal Wear Infinite waterproof is supposed to be best, it's not a solid/dark of a line as I prefer but it is quite smooth and stays longer than even some department store brands.
i am an eyeliner junkie. its my vice. if i had to have one product on, it'd be eyeliner! i've used ones from $1 to $30. like wet n' wild, revlon, maybelline, almay, styli style...you name it... but my favorite is MAC fluidline. its a gel in a pot, and you apply it with a flat, stiff bristle brush. it lasts ALL day even, when i got thrown into the pool a couple of times unexpectedly last week:) you can apply it for a liquid look, or pencil look. (i had a friend who used it, and i had no idea bc i thought it was pencil!) but you can't really tell what method its been put on. its $16, but a little pot will last you a while. If that method is too much for you, try the MAC powerpoint eye pencil, thats another lasting one. I also love Chanel's aqua proof eyeliner, its $25..a little pricey but worth it.